Difference Between Recommended & Mandatory Shots

Parents bring their sick children into the doctor’s office who then recommends various vaccines for his/her safety. The schedule of vaccines spans over months/years and requires parents to respect all the appointments. Though remembering all dates is not a piece of cake, using a pill tracker app will make it a lot easier for you.

Common query parents make during appointments is “Are vaccinations a must? Because if not, we’ll pass.”

They may have several reasons for being reluctant. But the one that confuses them the most in determining whether or not recommended vaccines are mandatory.

Not only parents but health professionals are also confused over the distinction between recommended and mandatory shots. But understanding differences between the two can protect your child against many viruses.

To develop that understanding, here’s what you need to know.

Who Sets Vaccine Recommendations

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) sets vaccine recommendations every year for the whole country. A panel of 15 experts (ACIP) puts together those recommendations. These experts are from various medical branches such as doctors, researchers, and disease specialists, etc.

Every set of recommendations is meant to provide maximum protection against vaccine-preventable diseases. Different schedules are created for different age groups – all of which can be followed using a medication reminder app.

For instance, CDC suggests that a healthy 11-year-old should get four shots to keep away meningitis, severe cough, and flu.

The schedule is updated annually to ensure the inclusion of the latest vaccine-related researches. It’s then utilized by healthcare specialists to inoculate patients, and at times by federal governments to figure out what antibodies should be required for school.

Mandatory Vaccinations

For school immunizations, each state makes its own set of recommendations for students before they enter specific grades or reach a certain age, or they won’t be allowed in classes. Accordingly, vaccine schedules vary widely across the country. For example, students are required to have at least one shot of meningococcal antibody in Kansas before entering the eighth grade, but neighboring states don’t have such requirements.

The time of updating vaccine schedules also varies from state to state. In some states, the governing bodies meet only once every 2 years, meaning that updates will be made every two years instead of annually.

The methods of choosing new antibodies also differ by state. Some states may pass a legislation to order antibodies for specific students, while others may simply release a statement about what should be required for schools. Like the CDC, these authorities regularly depend on research to make new vaccine additions. However, factors like cultural norms may also be considered.

For instance, flu virus immunization is consistently prescribed by CDC to adjust to the changing infections that pop up during every flu season. However, confirming that each student took his/her shots every year would be a huge task for health officials, and thus, is not viewed as feasible by state governments.

Additionally, states can require vaccinations for certain groups such as college students or government employees. Private businesses and companies can likewise require employees to take certain vaccinations, for example, the staff at hospitals is required to be inoculated against hepatitis B.

Mandatory Vs Forced Vaccinations

The idea of “forced immunization” is a violent one. While the assumptions of babies being pinned down by health officials during vaccinations are true to some extent – the reality is not as intense.

All 50 states have sets of antibody recommendations for kids, but that doesn’t mean children are being forced to take shots. The rules are only limited to students. Parents who are against shots always have the opt-out option.

In each state, kids are allowed to skip immunizations for medical reasons such as serious disease or allergies. Also, apart from the states of California, Mississippi, and West Virginia, all states allow parents to skip immunizations for non-medical reasons such as personal beliefs or religious objection.

Some states have even made the procedure for getting non-medicinal exceptions as simple as ABC. However, most states still require parents to follow a grueling process of learning the benefits and risks of immunization before they can get an exemption.

Homeschooled kids are exempted from school immunizations as well.

However, even with all these exceptions, just around 2 percent of students actually skip them.

Importance of Vaccines

While states continue to expand immunization requirements every year, they are not as complete and effective as the CDC schedule.

For instance, plenty of states make meningococcal and pertussis shots a must for students, but only two states require HPV and not even a single state requires influenza which causes far more deaths in the United States.

As indicated by a report, three cancer types caused by HPV kill approximately 7,000 individuals per year in the United States, while only 500 annual deaths are due to meningitis and pertussis.

Both fail to measure up to the evaluated 12,000-56,000 annual deaths caused by flu. This is the main reason CDC suggests antibodies against each of these infections for individuals of ages 11-12.

The antibodies that are not a must to take have a way of showing that they’re optional. For instance, the ACIP made the meningococcal B shot optional in 2015, essentially surrendering it over to healthcare specialists to choose whether a patient requires it or not.

Final Word

So, these are some facts on mandatory and recommended vaccines. While healthcare authorities and governments are pro-vaccines, the final decision will always belong to parents. Choose wisely what’s better for the health of your kid. And lastly, if your kid is already on vaccines, use a pill reminder app to ensure he/she never misses out on doctor appointments. Good luck!

5/5 (1 Review)